Lawyers Present FBI With a Dilemma in Hillary Clinton Email Server Investigation

DAILY CALLER — Lawyers seeking access to FBI records about Hillary Clinton’s private email server presented the Department of Justice with a dilemma on Monday when they filed a court document that may require the government to turn over the records or admit that the FBI investigation of the Clinton server is criminal in nature.

So far, the FBI has said that the Clinton email probe is an investigation, contrary to Clinton and Co.’s claim that it is a mere “security review.” But FBI Director James Comey last week declined to say whether the investigation is a criminal one.

Investigators are looking into whether classified information was mishandled on Clinton’s server.

In response to a federal lawsuit filed by Vice News reporter Jason Leopold seeking a variety of records related to the server, the government has claimed that it must keep the documents secret because they are part of a “pending or prospective law enforcement proceeding.”

In March, the Justice Department submitted a classified document in federal court calling for summary judgement of Leopold’s case. Leopold, who also filed the lawsuit that led to the release of Clinton’s State Department emails last year, sought correspondence between the FBI and the State Department and Clinton team regarding the email server. He also sought any emails that Clinton may have deleted but which were recovered by the FBI.

But Leopold’s lawyers, Ryan James and Jeffrey Light, argued in court papers filed Monday that the FBI has not provided enough evidence to justify the withholding.

They argue that in order to shield documents from production under the Freedom of Information Act, federal agencies “should be able to identify a particular individual or a particular incident as the object of its investigation and the connection between that individual or incident and a possible security risk or violation of federal law.”


Share Button

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *